Re: mm: delay rmap removal until after TLB flush

[David Hildenbrand]

On 03.11.22 18:09, Linus Torvalds wrote:
> On Thu, Nov 3, 2022 at 9:54 AM Linus Torvalds
> <torvalds@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> > But again, those changes would have made the patch bigger, which I
> > didn't want at this point (and 'release_pages()' would need that
> > clean-in-place anyway, unless we changed *that* too and made the whole
> > page encoding be something widely available).
>
> And just to clarify: this is not just me trying to expand the reach of my patch.
>
> I'd suggest people look at mlock_pagevec(), and realize that LRU_PAGE
> and NEW_PAGE are both *exactly* the same kind of "encoded_page" bits
> that TLB_ZAP_RMAP is.
>
> Except the mlock code does *not* show that in the type system, and
> instead just passes a "struct page **" array around in pvec->pages,
> and then you'd just better know that "oh, it's not *really* just a
> page pointer".
>
> So I really think that the "array of encoded page pointers" thing is a
> generic notion that we *already* have.
>
> It's just that we've done it disgustingly in the past, and I didn't
> want to do that disgusting thing again.
>
> So I would hope that the nasty things that the mlock code would some
> day use the same page pointer encoding logic to actually make the
> whole "this is not a page pointer that you can use directly, it has
> low bits set for flags" very explicit.
>
> I am *not* sure if then the actual encoded bits would be unified.
> Probably not - you might have very different and distinct uses of the
> encode_page() thing where the bits mean different things in different
> contexts.
>
> Anyway, this is me just explaining the thinking behind it all. The
> page bit encoding is a very generic thing (well, "very generic" in
> this case means "has at least one other independent user"), explaining
> the very generic naming.
>
> But at the same time, the particular _patch_ was meant to be very targeted.
>
> So slightly schizophrenic name choices as a result.

Thanks for the explanation. I brought it up because the generic name 
somehow felt weird in include/asm-generic/tlb.h. Skimming over the code 
I'd have expected something like TLB_ENCODE_PAGE_BITS, so making the 
"very generic" things "very specific" as long as it lives in tlb.h :)

--
Thanks,

David / dhildenb