Re: [PATCH] iommu/iova: Improve 32-bit free space estimate

From: Miles Chen
Date: Fri Mar 04 2022 - 19:03:48 EST


Hi Joerg, Robin,

> Applied without stable tag for now. If needed, please consider
> re-sending it for stable when this patch is merged upstream.

> Yeah, having figured out the history, I ended up with the opinion that
> it was a missed corner-case optimisation opportunity, rather than an
> actual error with respect to intent or implementation, so I
> intentionally left that out. Plus figuring out an exact Fixes tag might
> be tricky - as above I reckon it probably only started to become
> significant somwehere around 5.11 or so.
>
> All of these various levels of retry mechanisms are only a best-effort
> thing, and ultimately if you're making large allocations from a small
> space there are always going to be *some* circumstances that still
> manage to defeat them. Over time, we've made them try harder, but that
> fact that we haven't yet made them try hard enough to work well for a
> particular use-case does not constitute a bug. However as Joerg says,
> anyone's welcome to make a case to Greg to backport a mainline commit if
> it's a low-risk change with significant benefit to real-world stable
> kernel users.

Got it, thank you.
We will try to push to the android LTS trees we need.

Thanks,
Miles

>
> Thanks all!
>
> Robin.