Re: [PATCH] tracing/profile: Fix profile_disable vs module_unload

[Li Zefan]

>>>>>> Aahh, I see the bug, its only ftrace that knows about the module, not
>>>>>> tracepoints themselves, _that_ needs fixing.
>>>>> You could possibly do something like:
>>>>>
>>>>>  struct module *tp_mod = __module_address(&some_tp_symbol);
>>>>>  struct module *cb_mod = __module_text_address(func);
>>>>>
>>>>>  if (tp_mod && tp_mod != cb_mod) {
>>>>> 	ret = try_get_module(tp_mod);
>>>>> 	if (ret)
>>>>> 		goto fail;
>>>>>  }
>>>>>
>>>>> in register_trace_##name() or thereabout.
>>>>>
>>>> Actually I tried it, but it didn't work. As I said, You can't find
>>>> any tp symbol when registering tp callback. The same example again:
>>>>
>>>> 	In module bar, we have register_trace_foo()
>>>> 	In module foo, we have DEFINE_TRACE(foo) and trace_foo().
>>>>
>>>> bar doesn't know any symbol of foo, so it can't bump foo's refcnt,
>>> Well, clearly it knows about register_trace_foo() which itself knows at
>>> least one symbol that should be in module foo, right? How else could it
>>> register a callback in that module (if it were loaded)?
>>>
>>> It appears to use some intermediate code, in which case the intermediate
>>> code knows about foo, which too solves our problem.
>>>
>>>> *Note: you can load module bar without loading module foo*
>>> In which case the tracepoint registration fails, right?
>>>
>> No, it won't fail. ;)
>>
>> Instead, when foo is loaded, tracepoint_update_probe_range() will be
>> called, and the probe registered in bar will be added to the tracepoint.
> 
> *blink*
> 
> so we'll succeed in registering a tracepoint we know isn't there?
> 

Yeah, try this:

# cd sample/tracepoints/
# insmod tracepoint-probe-sample.ko	<--- load trace probe firstly
# insmod tracepoint-sample.ko           <--- load tracepoint secondly
# cat /proc/tracepoint-sample
cat: /proc/tracepoint-sample: Operation not permitted	<-- pls ignore this
# dmesg							<-- see the output of probe
Event is encountered with filename tracepoint-sample
Event B is encountered
Event B is encountered
Event B is encountered
Event B is encountered
Event B is encountered
Event B is encountered
Event B is encountered
Event B is encountered
Event B is encountered
Event B is encountered
--
To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-kernel" in
the body of a message to majordomo@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
More majordomo info at  http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html
Please read the FAQ at  http://www.tux.org/lkml/