On Monday 27 August 2007 17:51, James Chapman wrote:
In the second half of my previous reply (which seems to have been deleted), I suggest a way to avoid this problem without using hardware interrupt mitigation / coalescing. Original text is quoted below.
>> I've seen the same and I'm suggesting that the NAPI driver keeps
>> itself in polled mode for N polls or M jiffies after it sees
>> workdone=0. This has always worked for me in packet forwarding
>> scenarios to maximize packets/sec and minimize latency.
To implement this, there's no need for timers, hrtimers or generic NAPI support that others have suggested. A driver's poll() would set an internal flag and record the current jiffies value when finding workdone=0 rather than doing an immediate napi_complete(). Early in poll() it would test this flag and if set, do a low-cost test to see if it had any work to do. If no work, it would check the saved jiffies value and do the napi_complete() only if no work has been done for a configurable number of jiffies. This keeps interrupts disabled longer at the expense of many more calls to poll() where no work is done. So critical to this scheme is modifying the driver's poll() to fastpath the case of having no work to do while waiting for its local jiffy count to expire.
The problem I see with this approach is that the time that passes between
two jiffies might be too long for 10G ethernet adapters.
(I tried to implement
a timer based approach with usual timers and the result was a disaster).
HW interrupts / or HP timer avoid the jiffy problem as they activate softIRQs
as soon as you call netif_rx_schedule.